Name: Bay Street Tattoo Co.
Address: 322 E Bay St, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, 53207, US
Telephone: (414) 483-5000
Rating: 4.8

About Bay Street Tattoo Co.

Bay Street Tattoo Co. is a tattoo and piercing shop located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The shop offers a range of services, including custom tattoos, piercings, and jewelry sales. The shop is open Tuesday through Saturday from 10:00 am to 6:00 pm, and closed on Mondays and Sundays.

The shop has received a mix of positive and negative reviews from customers. Some customers have praised the shop for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, clean environment, and quality work. Customers have also appreciated the shop's attention to detail and willingness to work with them to create custom designs.

However, some customers have expressed frustration with the shop's communication and response time. Some customers have reported difficulty getting in touch with the shop to schedule appointments or inquire about specific services.

Despite these mixed reviews, Bay Street Tattoo Co. remains a popular choice for those seeking tattoos and piercings in the Milwaukee area. The shop's experienced artists and friendly staff create a welcoming environment for customers of all ages and backgrounds.

If you are looking for a tattoo or piercing, Bay Street Tattoo Co. is worth considering. However, it is recommended that you do your research and read reviews from other customers before making a final decision.

Reviews (99)

Max Garcia

★★☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

I got a piercing here a year ago. It was great! The piercer was really calm and nice and was okay with me being nervous. But now a year later its time to change my jewelry and I know the gauges are available on their website but I don't see my specific piercing listed. I have called, emailed, texted on google, and tried instagram. I haven't gotten a reply when I'm really disappointed about so I have to go about figuring out the gauge myself. EDIT: I am trying to figure out the gauge of a septum piercing they use. The link provided doesn't show the gauge and neither does the website. I am left to just guess "nose ring" might mean septum

nora allison

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Sheri is an amazing piercer. I came in with mismatched existing piercings and with her expertise we were able to create two balanced ears using new and old piercings! Everything is super clean and pleasant!

Bernie Hauerwas

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Highly recommend Bay Street for your piercing needs! Super friendly and clean!

Nabeel Deane

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I had an amazing first tattoo experience with Walt. He is not only an amazing and detail oriented artist, but a really cool dude. 6 hour tattoo and no awkward pauses. Dude is a pure professional, and gives you a solid therapy session on top of his artwork. I plan on coming back for my next, and will be sure to recommend him to my body art fan friends.

Cheryl Basina

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Awesome job, very artistic..... beautiful work I'm definitely going back....you need to book your next tattoo here!!!!! Trust me !!!!

Sam Losinski

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Just killing it, thanks Walt 🤝

Hanna Marks

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Went to Bay Street tattoo for the first time this week. Walt did my tattoo, I had a meeting to describe what I wanted (fine line 4444 in gothic print, not too crazy) and he totally nailed it. He understood my vision and I am SO happy with the final product. It was also very modestly priced! Overall very good experience and I will be back!

Kira Peterson

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I just had the most wonderful experience earlier today! I went to get more piercings done and the staff were incredible. Super patient and thoughtful and were flexible when I changed some of my ideas. Couldn’t recommend them more highly!

Stephanie Hernandez

★☆☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

I had an initial tattoo consult appt in mid-November. I wanted to move forward with the next appt, so Walt gave me his email to directly contact him to set this up, saying that I should be able to get in by December, when I was hoping to. I'm not sure about their turnaround time with emails...but after about 3 weeks, I got zero response to either of my emails or voicemail. Maybe there's a better contact method for this place? But after being given the email I should contact Walt at, I'm confused and disappointed by how my request was not responded to, even after I attended the initial appointment. Too bad - I was excited to try this place out for my first tattoo, after seeing all the great reviews.

RiRi Dinkins

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Absolutely AMAZING service! Sheri is a very sweet lady, and very skilled! My piercings were done quick and easy, and she gave a lot of good aftercare tips. Very clean and calm environment. I'll definitely be back!

Alyssa Edewaard

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I visited Bay Street Tattoo back in late July after pretty recently deciding to get a nose piercing with my friend. I had absolutely no idea where I wanted it or what style I wanted, but Sherri was patient with me as I decided and walked me through the options, offering her advice on what would be best. She kept steady and cheerful conversation throughout the whole process, calming absolutely any nerves ever and geeking out with me over Harry Potter :) In the end, I was given a natural cleaning solution and told to come back if I had any issues. I was returning home to Florida the next day, so returning wasn’t an option, but it healed perfectly and i have had no need to return since!! I have also been told how perfectly it was placed many times, and that’s all on her! Thank you for making my first (non-ear) piercing as quick, enjoyable, and painless as possible!

Steph E

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

This is the best experience I’ve ever had with a piercer! Sheri is so personable and makes you comfortable through the whole process! I wouldn’t go to anyone else!

Michelle C

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Very clean establishment. Polite and kind staff. Recommend!

Diane Gregory

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Had a consultation with Walt, 👍 I know I can trust him with my 1st tattoo! Ok!! Got my tattoo yesterday, love it! Really happy with the size & placement, very cool!

Liam Odden

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I have been pierced a good amount of times in my life, and this has been, by far, the best of them all. Thank you, Sheri!

LLJ LLJ

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Let me tell you I’m very picky and have to do massive research before deciding on important things in my life! My daughter received a second ear piercing and I received a nose piercing. Sherri is excellent! She worked well with my daughter and myself! She explained the process well and didn’t rush us through anything! I highly recommend…it’s an all around good vibe. Here’s to Happy Healing 🙏🏽

Lindsay Kampschroer

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I've gotten a tattoo and a piercing at Bay Street and both experiences were amazing. Walt and Sheri provided great customer service and made me feel comfortable and relaxed. They both answered all my questions regarding aftercare and the healing process. Definitely will be back for more in the future.

Amy

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Had a tragus piercing done by Sheri, and she was very nice/informative with the piercing process. My piercing is healing great as well.

Jack L. Moon

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Always love Walt and his work. Only person I'll let anywhere near me with a tattoo needle!

Renee Turco

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Sheri is absolutely wonderful! I had my first cartilage piercing done (3 push pin piercings) and couldn't be happier. The shop is very clean and Sheri takes the time to understand what you want, then makes perfect judgement in placing the piercing locations. She ensures that you are fully informed about proper aftercare do's and don'ts as well. I am thrilled that I took the time to research and read reviews from other clients. Highly recommend!