Name: Colts Timeless Tattoos
Address: 2065 American Dr Suite C, Neenah, Wisconsin, 54956, US
Telephone: (920) 380-2300
Rating: 4.6

About Colts Timeless Tattoos

Colts Timeless Tattoos: If you're looking for a tattoo or piercing shop in Neenah, Colts Timeless Tattoos is a great option. This shop offers both tattoo and piercing services, making it a one-stop-shop for all your body art needs.

The shop is open from 11:00 am to 7:00 pm Monday through Friday, making it convenient for those who work during the day. Unfortunately, the shop is closed on weekends, so you'll need to plan accordingly if you want to get a tattoo or piercing on a Saturday or Sunday.

Customers rave about the cleanliness of the shop, as well as the friendly and knowledgeable staff. Many customers specifically mention the excellent work done by Carli, Mandy, and Abby.

One customer describes the vibe of the shop as "super chill," with heavy metal music not being blasted at full volume. This customer also praises Carli's outstanding work and excellent communication during the tattoo process.

Another customer notes that Abby is the best piercer they've ever been to, while a third customer appreciates the shop's responsiveness and friendliness when they contacted them for more information.

While some customers have mentioned the shop's minimum charge, others have noted that the shop's work is worth the price. Overall, Colts Timeless Tattoos is a great option for those looking for a clean, friendly, and professional tattoo and piercing shop in Neenah.

Reviews (100)

Connie K

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I had an appointment scheduled with Carli yesterday. Due to a weird glitch with the scheduling software, my appointment didn't show up on their calendar even though I'd confirmed it ahead of time. But the folks behind the desk were super helpful, and Carli came in right away! We managed to get everything done on time and nothing felt rushed. I felt super comfortable in the space, and Carli was fantastic to work with. Carli does amazing work, and Colt's is a great space.

Jo Higdon

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

My tattoo was done perfectly. Friendly staff, nice and clean, and very professional. Couldn't be happier with my tattoo

Amber Moericke

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Abby will forever be my favorite!! She’s done so many of my piercings. And she’s honestly so sweet and just the best. Talks you through the whole process and makes you beyond comfortable! I also love balam! Does amazing work and just so friendly!

Brittany Kinnard

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Came in because I lost my nosering and andy the receptionist was so nice and even gave me a monstera plant. Exceptionally nice people, the kind you dont meet everyday🖤

TaylorAnn

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I went in to get Piercings Done by abby and She was amazing i felt safe and comfortable I highly recommend

Eden Rawr

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Vibe check - Passed! Super chill atmosphere. They go above and beyond to make you feel at home and safe. Heavy metal was not blasted at full volume. Carli did my tattoo. Her work was outstanding, and she was an absolute pleasure to be around! Carli kept in great communication with me during the entire process. I will definitely be going back!!!

Chris Jackson

★☆☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

I'm sure they do great work, but unfortunately we didn't even get to that point. I understand the necessity of a shop minimum. However, when you only need a $150 piece, I can't see a $300 minimum being justifiable.

Katie Marie

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Excellent experience! What a great place, very clean, friendly & fun staff, and welcoming environment. I had two sessions with Mandy, the first being a cover-up and the second an add on. Going in for my first session, was nerve-wracking. I did not know what she would come up with. With that being said her drawing was absolutely beautiful, but not me. She was kind enough to discuss what I should be looking for in a design to cover the previous tattoo. Since I really was looking for something that shows my country girl vibe and memories of my childhood I thought a sunflower would be great. Beautifully done, I loved my sunflower, but felt it looked lost. I knew I needed to add on! Of course after my first session, I knew exactly where and who was going to do it! Mandy totally rocked it, starting with a simple design we collaborated to add the final meaningful touches. With much anticipation, the design was lovely!! Once done, the fine details blew me away! Mandy does a fantastic job! Be sure to book your appointment with the very talented Mandy!

Lauren Aho

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Abby was very knowledgeable and friendly. Best piercer I’ve been to hands down.

Emily Anderson

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I don't live in the area and I come here for my tattoos. Book in advance with an artist. You can walk in for a consult if necessary. The space is clean and well decorated. I always have a great time when I am here

Kay K

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I've been getting tattooed at Colt's over the span of 15 years. Excellent, passionate artists who do incredible work every single time.

M Lynn

★☆☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

All I wanted was two small triangles in one color, about the size of a 50 cent piece. I was told it would be 100 dollars to just to get "on her floor". Ridiculous! I even had a picture with me to show her what I wanted.

Savanna Lee

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Mandy was my artist and she was super friendly and did a great job on my tattoo! The staff at the front desk were also very kind and I felt very welcomed there!

Sami Abhold

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Everyone here is super nice, and Abby is amazing! Talked me throughout the whole piercing. Super fast and nonpainful! Will always go here and see her!

Tansy Van Lankvelt

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Abby pierced my second lobe and helix. I'm needle phobic and was pretty nervous once I got there, but it went really well. I wasn't even nauseous. Pain level was super low and she had tons of great advice - like a donut shaped pillow for side sleeping. She was clearly super knowledgeable. I'll definitely be back for more once these heal up :)

Dana Dee

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I recently was tattooed by Carli and I cannot recommend her services and this location enough. The facility was clean and professional and the receptionist Andy was so warm and welcoming. Carli was so kind and easy to talk to, and her tattoo work is incredible! Absolutely my go-to tattoo artist from now on. Seriously, give these guys a call, you won’t be disappointed!

Victoria Gau

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

The people were great, very nice and clean space. I absolutely love the work I got done too!

thecuriouselena

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

First of all, I showed up 10 minutes late. Don't be like me. Anyway, despite me being late, they were so nice and understanding with me. Abbey did a great job with my double nose piercing and was thorough about the after care. I also ended up getting a little faint (I forgot to eat before hand) and she was so attentive- getting me juice, water and a Granola bar and waiting patiently until I felt well enough to get up. 1000% recommend this place. Also the building itself is so cool inside.

Always Abby

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I didn’t actually get a tattoo from this place, but I did contact them for more information. They were super helpful and got back to me very quickly!!

Dan Normington

★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

From the very beginning Colt's Timeless Tattoos was amazing. The staff were incredibly responsive and friendly. Matt did a fantastic job coming up with a unique design incorporating everything I wanted in my tattoo. Will definitely be coming back.