Review of Bay Street Tattoo Co.
Bay Street Tattoo Co. is a tattoo and piercing shop located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The shop offers a range of services, including custom tattoos, piercings, and jewelry sales. The shop is open Tuesday through Saturday from 10:00 am to 6:00 pm, and closed on Mondays and Sundays.
The shop has received a mix of positive and negative reviews from customers. Some customers have praised the shop for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, clean environment, and quality work. Customers have also appreciated the shop's attention to detail and willingness to work with them to create custom designs.
However, some customers have expressed frustration with the shop's communication and response time. Some customers have reported difficulty getting in touch with the shop to schedule appointments or inquire about specific services.
Despite these mixed reviews, Bay Street Tattoo Co. remains a popular choice for those seeking tattoos and piercings in the Milwaukee area. The shop's experienced artists and friendly staff create a welcoming environment for customers of all ages and backgrounds.
If you are looking for a tattoo or piercing, Bay Street Tattoo Co. is worth considering. However, it is recommended that you do your research and read reviews from other customers before making a final decision.
From the business
"Bay Street Tattoo has been tattooing and body piercing in Milwaukee since June of 1999. We are a women owned business and always have been. We are a custom tattoo shop and would love to draw you the tattoo of your dreams. Black & grey, color, or cover-up we are happy to help. The shop carries a large collection of body jewelry including genuine gemstones, gold, and acrylic of all styles. If you are looking for something and we don't carry it, we are happy to order it for you or make it to fit your needs. Give us a call or stop in today!"
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- In-store shopping
Bay Street Tattoo Co. Reviews - 99
Add Review
Hells Belle39
Yesterday afternoon I went in to have my earlobes re-pierced (having a severe nickel allergy, I've had to have all of my piercings taken out: industrial, lobes, cartilage, industrial, eyebrow, lip and tongue), and I was Very happy I did!!!
Sheri was my piercer, and I waited patiently as she finished up with a first-time nose piercing. What a wonderful lady!! Her very presence is serene and puts people at ease, she's very knowledgeable, and my ears were done in seconds with No pain at all!! I also purchased a bottle of their all-natural healing solution and it feels amazing on my new piercings.
This is an amazing shop, and I will be going there for all of my future piercings (if my lobes decide to heal with no problem that is!), and most likely for any future tattoos!
Jack L. Moon
Always love Walt and his work. Only person I'll let anywhere near me with a tattoo needle!
Charlotte Anderson
Sheri is an absolute rockstar!!!!!! i’m absolutely terrified of needles - but finally got the courage to get my septum pierced & after googling i found Bay Street. i’m so so glad i did!! Sheri was so kind & great, explaining the whole process but the best part was that she was super quick!! and gentle!! i just got my nostril pierced tonight and it was honestly such a breeze because i had an amazing experience the first time. i will for sure be coming back ! :)
Samantha Thomfohrda
I called in asking if Sheri could squeeze me in for a nose and 2 lobe piercings— she was able to right away! I came in and was there for maybe 15 minutes. She was was kind, informative, and comforting. The shop was super cute and clean. I will definitely be back for more piercings in the future and maybe another tattoo 🎨🦋✨Highly recommend. 🌈
Rasaan Sanders
They did a great job with the eyebrow piercing but be aware that they over charge for service.
Eyebrow Piercing (Barbell)
$ 45.00
Price includes standard starter jewelry. $10 deposit is required to hold your appointment and will come off the total cost of your service.
Above was copied directly from their website. Yet I was charge 47.50 for the piercing and I was also charged $10 to hold my appointment. So total I paid $57.50 for the piercing. Their website should be changed for false advertising. Happy with the piercing disappointed
that I was over charged. I will not return and would not recommend. To me this is sneaky and misleading, there is trust lost.
Abigail Falconero
I was looking for a place in Milwaukee that is in a safe neighborhood to get my navel piercing done. I found Bay Street Tattoo Co. by google search and made a appointment with Sheri. It was my first piercing besides my standard earlobe ones and I was nervous. Sheri was so nice, professional and made the whole process so easy. She explained everything she did beforehand and was extremely informative on the aftercare process and talked to me about a tattoo I have been wanting. She explained that the shop really valued their work and customers which definitely shined through. I will be coming back for my next tattoo or piercing. High recommend this place!!
Ann Nordeen
Took my 13 year old to get her ears double pierced. Sheri was very kind and engaging. My daughter still claims she felt nothing - she was totally shocked at the ease of the experience. Very clean and professional- would recommend to anyone!! Very pleased with the WHOLE experience!! Thank you!
Roxanne Murillo
My daughter just received two nose piercing today! One side was a stud and the other a ring! Sheri was so nice and professional. I would recommend her to everyone! Don’t miss out on this great place!
Joanna Amborn
I am so happy with my tattoo experience at Bay Street! The shop is clean with solid COVID protocols. Walt did an amazing job, both on the tattoo and providing a comfortable experience. I was relatively nervous, but felt very relaxed after settling in. Highly recommended, will be back!
Kosmos Knovas
The woman behind the counter with the most beautiful silver colored hair was so incredibly polite and kind and quick (the whole process took less then a minute). I was genually not the happiest person that day walking in (this was literally yesterday 🤣 2/10/2022) ... I should have called before hand but I'm being a fool and lost in my own. Anyway, she was so genuine it made me feel great and she did pierce my nose, I have a chiari malformation so this piercing is supposed to help with headaches to any degree, so here's goes crossing my fingers. 🥳anyway, this place is great, I will be back for a touch up on my ankle tattoo just as I said I would before leaving 🥰 maybe extra work!!! Thank you again for taking me in 🥰