Silver Tuna Tattoo and Piercing

Mertzy, Sara, and Colton are by far the most caring, wonderful, amazing, talented tattoo artists and piercing artists I have ever met. Living in Wisconsin we have come to expect snow and Sara made it a point to reach out to me the night before we were supposed to get a big storm to see if I would want to reschedule for MY safety. Having lived here all my life and very close to the shop I said nah we should be good.
Then she messaged me to see if I wanted to come in early. I mean seriously!? YES!!!

Then I asked Mertzy if he wouldn’t mind doing another small tattoo for me and he did!! Sara also helped my fiancé start the process of gauging his ears! They went above and beyond for us and I am so lucky to know these fantastic people
I have never met a more caring bunch of talented individuals and hilarious down to earth too boot!
I will always be a client at the Silver Tuna! If you have t been there ABSOLUTELY go!! 100% recommend!!

Silver Tuna is by far the best shop that I have ever been to. Sarah (piercer) and Mertzy (tattoo artist) are so amazing at what they do. They are very easygoing and laid back but yet still able to focus on their work. It is very obvious they are clean and sanitary which is HUGE for me. Not to mention their pricing is very comparable to other places, and their quality and comfort is wonderful. They make such a great team. I will not go anywhere else for my piercing and tattoo wants. I will recommend them to everyone.

I brought my 16 year old daughter to Sarah for a basic earlobe piercing after a previous mishap at Clairs. She advised we wait 6 weeks to let them heal completely and then come back for the repiercing. Sarah was tedious at making sure the piercings were perfectly straight and explained the process as she went along. Everything was very clean and I trusted her completely to pierce her ears. She explained the aftercare thoroughly and we left with the cleaning product and an aftercare sheet... plus some fun stickers. My daughter's ears weren't even red or swollen and she told me she forgot they were even in that night since they didn't hurt one bit. I completely recommend Sarah for piercings she knows her stuff.

The people that own/work in this shop are the most authentic, down to earth and accepting people I have met. I walked in and felt like we had all been friends for years. Besides the excellent people skills they harbor they are also so creative and talented. I fully recommend this place. Another thing I'd like to shed some light on is what they have done for the community; especially their work with Toys For Tots.

Thanks guys for my beautiful piece.

Got my first ever tattoo here and Kelly did a great job. Felt very comfortable and and definitely going back again!

Sarah did a phenomenal job on my nipple piercings. I was so nervous walking into a building I never went to before, but she was so reassuring and made me feel so comfortable. Sarah talked me through the process and didn't judge me when I screamed a bit loud. She is everything you want in a piercer. I left Silver Tuna feeling so confident and loving my new piercings. Highly recommend for anyone looking to get something fun added to your body. Thanks a bunch Sarah!!!

Silver Tuna is one of the best shops in the state. From their top notch customer service to the personalized custom experience for each individual customer it would be difficult to find a better tattoo and piercing establishment. Not only do I endorse this shop it's the only place I will ever go. Kelly Mertz and Sarah Hansen have set the bar high for all other shops not only in the valley but the state as a whole!

I've been getting work done at shops around appleton and madison and this BY FAR my favorite. The atmosphere is professional but exceptionally comfortable and laid back, not to mention I LOVE the decor. I swear tattoos hurt less here too ;) You folks have a great thing going, keep it up!

Mertzy is amazing at what he does and so easy to talk to. He will offer his professional opinion on placement and design and make sure you’re completely happy with your design before starting. The shop is clean, warm and inviting. Feels like you’re walking into someone’s home. LOVE it there!!! Sarah is also awesome at what she does. She can do super cool anodized jewelry to make your piercing pop. Need some ink or a great piercing or 2, this is your place.

I love this place for piercing jewelry!! Sarah is super friendly and will go out of her way to get you exactly what you want. This is my new go-to for all piercing jewelry.