Colts Timeless Tattoos

The atmosphere is BEYOND incredible! They make you feel comfortable from the moment you walk in the door which is incredibly hard to find at some places. The work I had done from their guest artist Nico will never be topped!

They have a great location at the mall upstairs and their prices are fair. My friend has gotten a few tattoos done there, and I decided to use the same artist as her. I got a fox done right above my left breast, and since my shirt wouldn't pull down to give the artist easy access, I had to remove my shirt. I used my hoodie to cover myself, and the artist was cool about it. I love my tattoo, but I'm disappointed he messed up some important color on it that would've changed the entire feel of the tattoo.

I had a finger tattoo that I have absolutely hated for the past 4-5 years. I have asked several artists to do a cover up, but they all said that they couldn’t do it. Matt Binder was willing to help, and he did a beautiful coverup. I could not be happier! The shop has a wonderful atmosphere, I felt super comfortable the whole time. Everyone was very friendly.
Huge shout out to Kelsey for her impeccable customer service. She set up the appointment for me and guided me to the perfect artist to do my coverup.
Highly recommend this tattoo shop. They have a great variety of artists/styles.

Carli was so amazing! Her attention to detail is quite stunning. This establishment is so Beautiful and relaxing!! Everyone was friendly! Definitely will be back.

I have only ever been pierced with a gun, and after more research I've realized that it's unsanitary and less safe than getting a piercing from a professional. Going in to get four more ear piercings at Colts was sort of scary, but after being greeted with a super friendly staff - I was totally ecstatic! The atmosphere was relaxing and really made me feel safe. Plus, the actual piercing room had a lot of nice things to look at while I was getting pierced. My piercer was super kind, and the whole experience was relatively painless and super quick! I didn't even know he was finished with one ear because I expected it to take longer! But no, everything was a total breeze, and he made sure I was comfortable. Overall I'm super happy with how my four new piercings turned out, and I'm totally going to go back for any more piercings I want to get in the future!

The communication is awful.

This shop has ZERO understanding of customer service. I spent weeks emailing and communicating with colts wife "who handles all of his communication" practically begging them to give me a tattoo. My budget is $2000+ and I wanted to have a 3/4 sleeve done, but after weeks of emailing, i was told they didn't want to do the style of tattoo I was asking for... What? The inspiration photo I sent them was directly from the colts instagram page of his own work.. On the photo it says he would love to do more work like this please reach out.

After weeks of slow communication from them and then being told colt didn't want my business and had no interest in doing that type of tattoo anymore, they offered to have me work with another one of their artists.. I agreed and sent additional inspiration photos. It has now been almost a full month and the shop just stopped communicating with me. They clearly dont want my business.. I honestly think I couldn't be an easier client. I have a loose idea of what I want and asked that the artist use their creative license...

At this point I believe I dodged a bullet and will be happy to spend a few thousand somewhere else.

Sooooo.... i went searching online for a good tattoo artist in wisconsin when i came across carli's work and decided that she was the one for me.... i reached out to her and discussed what i was looking for (coverup), budget concerns and other questions on the work i was looking for. she responded in such a timely manner and had answered all of my questions along with some advice. i booked and was not dissapointed AT ALL

she even reached out to me the day prior to let me know that she was going to send me the tattoo design she thought would work best on the area, and i thought that that was such a professional gesture, and was much appreciated....

i was nervous coming into this but she reassured me that she was going take care fo me and that she did! i will definitely be going back!!!! such a doll and professional young woman.

def worth the 1.5hr drive!

Going in on a walk in Saturday’s are awesome! I went twice in a row and the first tattoo came out amazing thanks to Josiah! And my second one came out beautiful as well thanks to Matt!! They are very friendly and helpful with your tattoo desires!! If you do go to Colts on a walk in Saturday make sure to get there early!

Amazing customer service! Matt is so good at what he does, my tattoos were perfect and he made the experience an easy one.

I’ve only had piercings done here, but Abby is amazing! I would highly recommend her. She is always super friendly and is very good at what she does. I had to get a dermal of mine removed due to it being very irritated, Although painful, Abby did everything to help make me as comfortable as possible and it was very quick.